Census, Caste, and Politics Print E-mail

( 5 Votes )
Columns - Readers Write
Written by Dr. Ajay Kumar, Norfolk, England   
Monday, 10 May 2010 19:11

It is not only sad but shocking to see politicisation of the forthcoming census. In Bihar, Mr. Nitish Kumar demands caste census. At the centre, Mr. Pranab Mukherjee demands the same. What is it behind their demand?

Obviously identification and localization of a particular group of people for the benefit of vote bank so that a section of community can be targeted in order to keep these politicians in power living a life of five-star comfort.

It also will put one community against the other.

And what benefit the common man will get? A few more millions will be driven into poverty just as one hundred million Indians have recently joined the category of "below poverty line". I just cannot comprehend what useful purpose it is going to serve. Can we not treat each human being as a human being rather than labeling him a Kurmi, a Brahman, a Kayasth, a Mushar or a Paasi? Can anyone tell me how to identify an individual of a particular caste in a crowded railway compartment or a crowd of people? Have they horn, three eyes, four hands, two mouths?

Caste is what made Bihar a poor, destitute, corrupt and crime ridden backward state. It is shocking that a Chief Minister of Bihar talking about caste. True, he did come to power on caste-based politics but he must never forget that he is the Chief Minister of Bihar and all Biharis, not the Chief Minister of a particular caste.

By demanding caste based census, he is not only encouraging casteism - a deadly evil in Bihar - but at the same time, dividing Biharis instead of uniting them. I blame Pranab Mukherjee too for his stupid statement that caste be considered in the next census.

India is burning. There is insurgency in the Northeast, Kashmir. There is Naxalite menace, female foeticide, honour killing, anti-North Indian persecution in Maharashtra, 75% of politicians are siphoning tax payers money into their Swiss Bank account; everyday thousands join the group of "below poverty line", malnourished children, hunger, anaemic women, no electricity, road, health care, education even after 63 years of independence, caste war and bloodshed, poor law and order situation.

The list goes on and on. And now, each Bihari and Indian will be asked what caste he/she belongs to. But then how can one say that a particular person really belongs to a particular caste? What are the visible signs on his body?

Please stop this nonsense of caste-based census. These are the things that divide a community, sow the seeds of discontent and resentment. These are the reason why we do not feel proud to call ourselves Indians. May I call upon every Indian and Bihari to rise up, say enough is enough and refuse to say which caste he/she belongs to?


Similar/Related Articles
No related articles found...
Share
 

Show Other Articles Of This Author

Comments  

 
+3 # Ranjit Varma 2010-05-14 01:09
ABSOLUTELY --- if only the so called 'literate' class of people totally deny filling in the caste on forms!!

My personal experience --- in 1978, when I had joined a very renowned company in Bihar, I refused to fill in my 'caste' on the form. The HR manager literally black-mailed me that I will NOT get the job if I left it blank. So I filled in 'Indian'. He glared at me, and warned me. Then on his persistence, I modified it to 'Indian/Hindu'. After a lot of "main-main-tu-tu" -- and because I was a candidate that they did not want to lose as I had topped the list of 13,000 applicants from all over India -- the HR Manager calculated that because my last name was 'x' - I must be of 'x' caste -- and he filled it in himself!! What followed was more hilarious --- I refused to join!! The hiring people were taken aback - and finally scraped out the caste from my form. I joined, and worked for 10 years before migrating to U.S.A. in 1988!!

Right through my School and College, and even today, I refuse to accept caste related 'stuff' -- my friends can vouch for that!! I have real friends – don’t care what caste they belong to -- a good person is a good person, a bad one is bad!! What I believe in, I start at home!!

I strongly believe that all of us should REFUSE to accept such norms!! In this global world of today, caste does NOT resolve anything -- but it is still a gimmick being used by corrupt people to fill their own pockets!!

We should concentrate more on educating ourselves, and also educating others!! Supporting such ills is also a crime -- it is time when we STOP this division of humanity on 'caste' basis !!
 
 
+1 # Ranjit Varma 2010-05-14 21:59
I must add here that this website - patna daily - is read by us who have enough knowledge about computers !! Means that we are the so called "EDUCATED" ones !! I assume this forum a very good place to start this revolution !!
 
 
+2 # Alok Singh 2010-05-14 22:52
Kudos to you for standing up for what is right.

I also agree with Dr Kumar about this idicocy called caste factor in census. While I like Nitish Kumar, his support to this call reeks of pure, unaldulterated politics for politics sake. Shame on him!
 
 
+1 # Dr. A. Kumar 2010-05-22 23:58
How time has changed...!!!

In 1958, while filling my application form for matriculation examination in Monghyr, Bihar, my teacher Mr. Govind Jha, asked me not to write my surname as it loudly proclaimed caste. I did just that. Ever since, I have been Kumar. So things changed so much by 1978 that caste declaration became compulsory!
 
 
# S.S.Thakur 2010-07-08 20:50
Just hypocritical. I fail to understand the logic of hiding your caste. By all means this is your identity. What I feel we should change is our attitude. Attaching superiority to a one caste over the other is something obnoxious that not only the member of one caste but also the other caste should understand. It has been poisoned more by politicians than the common men. The attitude will change by providing education, employment, means of entertainment etc. If only the electricity problem is solved many social unrest will find its way to evaporating into productivity, better and peaceful life with opportunity to explore beyond your restricted walls.
 

If you wish to post comments on PatnaDaily.Com, you must register first. Read more about it here.