Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Time to Think Bihar

by Anjali Prasad

April 4, 2006

Readers Write

 

Ever thought or felt what people outside Bihar think of us? Many non-Bihari Indians gave me a look like I did a crime stating that I am from Patna. Till some years back I even had to go to the extent of making it clear that Patna is the capital of Bihar, not Jamshedpur. Thanks to our ex-Chief Minister I am saved the pain of explaining that part now. At least he made Patna quite famous and notorious to people all over the world! Now people target me with questions like is Bihar really all about crimes? I do not really blame them for this kind of reaction. We Biharis too have been pondering over this. I am proud of the people of Bihar who have in the past and who continue to prove themselves at par with others in their fields and reputed institutes. They at least bring a good and dignified name to Bihar.

What really disappoints me is that why has the typical so called Bihari tone become a source of amusement for other Indians? People from Bihar who differ slightly from this tone get the reaction like "oh, you don't look like a Bihari". What in the world do they mean by that? Do they think we Biharis can only converse in a style which they can make fun of? There are some people who genuinely like the way we say’ hum’ and related verbs in our conversation. These people actually give respect to our tone, but the truth is that our style of conversing has become a laughing matter for most.

Living out of Bihar, for a good period of my life, I found Biharis simple but more cultured, much mature, and even straightforward compared to many others. And you should never miss any party hosted by a Bihari. You will not see a happier host, serving you with lavish varieties of food and desserts.

There are also a few who actually hide their identities that they come from Bihar. I cannot help feeling sorry for them. We belong to the land of Pataliputra and Nalanda, which existed in the golden era of Indian history and should try to preserve its past glory. The colleges and universities of Patna with their grand buildings and scenic beauty along the side of river Ganga could have attained fame, but instead keep on deteriorating day by day. The people in politics and power continue to fail in paving a path for progress in Bihar. I believe it is now up to us to really bring about some changes and get back the respect and dignity we have lost.

Comments:
I agree with what you are saying. I used to work in an office where I was the only Bihari. The first day everybody turned and looked at me as if a museum specimen had arrived. But within few days everyone started speaking in my tone and they all became friendly. I think if you are firm with your identity everybody will show respect. Once a colleague commented on my tone and language. I asked him to check his language and pointed out what mistakes he makes while speaking. Uske baad kabhi problem nahi hua. - Richa - Apr. 7, 2006

I strongly believe that it is our media who has created the notion in people that "Bihari" is a derogatory word. At my work place, I was the only Bihari working in a team comprising of 13 individuals. None of them ever had visited Bihar. However, there were certain people who used to say Bihar as "separate country". Most of them were from so called "Progressive States" of India. I only had to tell them that in spite of they belonging to developed states of India what they had achieved! Have they achieved anything extraordinary in life for which they boast of? Or are they doing superior work compared to what I am doing? Let them realise that they won't be getting any special privileges anywhere just because they are not "Biharis"..

I agree that Bihar is suffering from misrule for last fifteen years, but what is ours fault? This type of perception is just a matter of shame for all Indians. The rulers of Bihar should be ashamed but not the Biharis. - Atul - Apr. 8, 2006


People who make such comments just show how ‘ignorant’ they are! I used to react to such situations when I was a kid and moved out of Patna to go to college for my engineering degree – but soon I realized that there is no point in doing so. I have stayed outside Bihar for 13 years now and have come across numerous such situations. After the first couple of years in college, whenever I heard such comments, I felt pity for the person making such comments – even today I do! We Biharis are really very simple people and we should continue to be that way – let’s not lose our heritage, we should be very proud of it. Let’s continue to bring glory to our great state by competing with the best of the world and proving ourselves – we have done that for thousands of years now and we should continue to do that. Our simple living and high thinking philosophy has helped us go places – I hope that generations to come will continue to imbibe and pass on these values.

EXTREMELY PROUD TO BE A BIHARI ! - Kush Kochgaway - Apr. 8, 2006


We have not lost our glory or dignity. As such, dignity comes from dignified way of thinking. Characters in Wordsworth poetry are very simple folk people but each character is a philosophy in today's meaning of modern life style. Kindergartens kids sing those common rhythmical lines of Wordsworth poetry with pleasure and delight. Majority of the people of Bihar during British Raj weren't highly educated: what then prompted/inspired Gandhi Ji to start Bharat Chhoro Aandolan from a small place like Champaran? Were the people of Delhi, Calcutta, Madras or Bombay not aware of Swatantra Sangram? Every Bihari is a Bihar. I will find myself belittled if some one fails to recognise me as Bihari. - Madani Mohiuddin Ahmad, KSU, Riyadh, KSA - Apr. 9, 2006


Whatever people say about Biharis, but what I have noticed is that wherever a Bihari is working he is among the top 10% of the best people in that organization. I guess that frustration from the people of the so called privileged places comes out by trying to look down upon you as being from an underdeveloped state. In my experience I have never reacted to people making such comments. Over a period of time, when you prove yourself, they themselves feel ashamed and stop making any such comments.

Later on as we keep growing, we come to a stage when whatever they think of Biharis, they'll never express it in front of you. Is liye mast raho, and don't care about what shallow people say. It reflects their own upbringing! - Dr. Lav Kochgaway, Kolkata - Apr. 9, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2006, PatnaDaily.Com.