Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Reservation, a Step Towards Social Welfare… or is it?

by Rakhee Sinha

April 29, 2006

Readers Write

 

A small hand quietly slipping into our hands, a shy and bright smile, innocent laugh, pure giggles give us the happiness that money cannot buy, the satisfaction that makes us feel warm from Inside and makes our lives beautiful, meaningful and much - much more…

Kids are the flowers that make our life glow with the innocent sparkle of their eyes and fragrant with the love in their hearts. Won’t we try our best to retain that fragrance and glow in our lives? Won’t we like to protect our vulnerable flowers, to fulfill their needs to let them grow and become a sincere, honest and reasonable citizen of India? We all want them to and many of us are working towards this goal. Still, there are some facts that compel us to extend our hands and support even more. Here are some of the facts that have been compiled from different sources.

• Every 2nd child has no access to primary education in India, in other words Half of India’s children are deprived of their fundamental right to education every day.

• Every 3rd girl child does not live to see her teen years in India…

• 111 million children of the 250 million child labor forces are Indian…

• Every hour, four women and girls in India enter prostitution, three of them against their will.

• There are no estimates of the number of children who are subjected to child-trafficking, debt-bondage, forced labor, pornography, prostitution and drugs, in India…

• 10,000 children die every single day in India. More than in any tsunami, flood, earthquake, famine or war.

• 51% of India’s children are blighted in childhood by malnutrition in India, the country that has food surplus.

The realization of these facts makes our hearts bleed. We work towards the goal to make a beautiful India, beautiful Bihar. We extend our wishes, our help, our money. We provide our support to the NGOs who are working towards this goal. We do everything that we can do in our own capacity, to feed our hope for a better future for India and Bihar, but where is it heading towards?

I feel the pain, I think… what is the Government doing to uplift these downtrodden people, to secure the future of these kids for whom their parents don’t even dare to see dreams, the kids who don’t know whether will they get their next meal. Yes, there is the Ray of Hope…Reservation. There they are, the messiah of poor, they are trying to secure the future of these kids, they are trying to reserve some good employment opportunities for these kids, what if they don’t get even their meals 2 times a day, what if they don’t even have access to the Primary Education. They don’t need a full stomach and of course not the Education. Aren’t there so many Angutha-Chhaap leaders? The same way, we can have some Angutha-Chhaap University students, IIT and IIM students. After- all these leaders are deciding our countries fate, what can we expect from them. Oh… I missed my theme, I was writing on the social issue of the kids, and I moved to the topic of Reservation. These two seem so different, not related at all, because, we all know the Truth ‘Reservation is not for the welfare of the downtrodden, but for the welfare of these leaders.’

The other bit of truth is that not all the people who are downtrodden are from the so-called OBC class, So, what about them? They don’t deserve anything because they didn’t born in an OBC community?

I know, we are having discussions, most of the intellectual people hate this word ‘Reservation’, but it won’t help. We will have to face a hard truth again that, our country is in the hands of politicians who don’t give a damn about the welfare of country and it’s people, and for reservation issue, they will get support of the creamy class of the co-called backward communities, because, this will be in favor of them. They are writing comments exploding with what they call ‘facts’ with figures, but deep down in their hearts, they too know what the truth is. This is the time we need to stop being selfish and oppose Reservation with a strong and united voice. With all the events and outsourcing of Jobs from USA and other countries, India is on the path of being a stronger and developed country; let’s not destroy the future of our country for very impractical selfish motives.

 

Comments:
The truth is — and this is the bottom line in the entire ‘reservation controversy’ — that although we have abolished unsociability and outlawed backwardness in our Constitution, many of us — even the most distinguished of us, alas — have not eliminated it from our hearts. In my last visit to India I asked one kid why you don’t go to school. He said Master Sahib who belongs to upper caste beats him because he is a lower caste. That’s how people conceive hatred. 10% of urban Indian don’t know what is happening in their village.

If the under-privileged have been oppressed for centuries, its backlash in the psychological make-up of the ‘privileged’ cannot be underestimated. “Dalits can ask Brahmins that if they were so meritorious, why is half of our country’s population still illiterate?” If meritorious economists and administrators manage the affairs of our country without any reservation how and why are we still so economically backward?”

In the end, the vexed problem about ‘reservations’ will only get resolved with more meaningful opportunities for better education of all sections of our society, particularly the under-privileged child.

But one thing is certain: as long as poverty continues to stalk the land and gross disparities between the rich and poor remain a fact of life, the ideal of an egalitarian society envisaged by the founding fathers in our basic document of governance will remain a bad dream. - Narayan Prasad - May 1, 2006

All human beings are same or equal was communist ideology which is proven to be wrong .

Truth is few people are superior than others and they are the one who will enjoy better life always.

For others only way to reach high is to work hard and struggle.

If lower castes of India understand this sooner it will be better for them. They should stop living in "Fools Paradise" of "Reservation", otherwise then will land in "Reserved" territory like American Indians sooner or later. - Manoj Gupta - May 1, 2006


I find it humiliating for the oppressed classes themselves to be considered "Intellectually Inferior". I consider that throwing quota at them is declaring them inferior. I find this to be an insult for OBCs, SCs ansd STs to offer reservation to them.

Have you seen the movie Iqbal? This is what I consider OBCs to be. They are intellectually capable of challenging everyone. Yes, they do need economical backing or even mentoring. BUT, I DO NOT APPRECIATE govt's reservation system to declare them Intellectually inferiors. - Subodh Kumar - May 3, 2006


Narayan Prasad Ji, your story about the little kid is heartbreaking. My advise to the little kids family will be to move out of the village to another state. Once you are out of your native place, and move to another state people will know you as a Bihari rather than as such and such caste person. This will help in building dignity and self-confidence in the children who are the future citizens of the society. I know that it is difficult for someone to move out of his or her native place but a place where you don't get dignity is worst that hell. You can still install dignity in a person if outsiders rather than his/her own kind humiliate him. One cannot even imagine such kind of situation in the US because of very strong laws against discrimination that are implemented strictly. To protect their children most people cannot escape to the US but they can definitely move out of the state. - Som Vishwakarma, USA - May 4, 2006


Hello Som,

Your suggestion for the kids family to leave the place is not viable. Where will they go?? Do you think if they move to different state, the situation will be better? I guess not. Instead one good action should have been to take strict action against that Master (who is elevated to the status of teacher and is directly responsible for spreading the caste hatred instead of telling children not to think about caste).

This "CASTE" is the greatest evil of today's society and even if you leave one place and go to other you will face it. It is ingrained into each and every person no matter how much educated he/she is. True, poverty is also problematic but even in poverty there is hierarchy. An upper caste poor will still be better than lower caste poor. This is the truth of our society.

Anyway one thing is that people do not look for reservation. They see reservation just as a tool to gain some DIGNITY. Alas there are so many Laws and Acts to prevent it, but none is followed. If that would not have been the case then there would not have been mass conversion to Buddhism (remember the father of our constitution also converted to Buddhism).

There is one very interesting piece of article http://www.asiasource.org/asip/dalits.cfm. This shows what is the percent of conviction rate for caste related crime. Also it gives an insight as to how things works in our society and what can be the various ways to discriminate between castes. The only way we can achieve a better society is not just by hitting at the grass root level but also at the branches simultaneously. Education is the first step that should be handled and implemented. And also how the education is being given. Compulsory education to all (grass root level). I think the best way to deliver the right kind of education will be to put the child right from the very early age in the hostels and let them grow with other children. This way they will be more influenced with other children and diversity and less with the family.

Also we have 'n' number of acts so we do not require more laws and acts. But those laws and acts should be implemented strictly (branch level). And it does not stop at that. If each one of us tries to convince at least one of other that caste is evil and we should remove it from our heart and see the other fellow as just human being, then probably our mission will be successful and hopefully the caste system will go away. And then we can proudly say that our children will be able to live in a better society where each one of us are more or less equal. - Gunjan, Bangalore - May 5, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2006, PatnaDaily.Com.