Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Raja Beta

by Som Vishwakarma
USA

April 12, 2006

Readers Write

 

I want to write about a common element in the Indian psyche that unfortunately doesn't have a word for it. So I am going ahead and coining the term 'Raja Beta' for it.

I will try to formulate and explain this term in the next few paragraphs.

Let's assume that there is a crook in our neighborhood. Everybody knows that this guy is a crook who lives on cheating and looting people. Now if someone goes to the mother of this crook and complains about it, she shouts and yells. She says, "How dare you complain about my dear Raja Beta". "You are ALL wrong!" "My Raja Beta is innocent and you are complaining because you are jealous of his success". "Agreed my Raja Beta is little bit naughty but didn't even Lord Krishna steal milk and curd".

A ‘bhadra log’ molests an innocent woman and his dharma patni shouts at the top of her lungs "how dare you complain about my swami". "The person who was molested must surely have bad character and is trying to implicate my innocent swami". "He is like Ram, he will never do this crime".

A husband and wife fight. The husband hits the wife and then asks her to cry softly so that the neighbor doesn’t hear her cry and the family sanskar/izzat is protected. It never occurred to the husband to protect the family sanskar/izzat by not hitting her in the first place!

A person complains about the bad situation in the country/state/city and everyone is up in arms against him/her. In case the person is from the same country/state/city he is called a traitor, in case the person is from another region he is called an 'outsider'. The corrupt local politicians have called even INFOSYS CEO an outsider. Tamil film star Rajni Kanth has been called an outsider when he tried to pass some social comments.

The list goes on and on. One has to have great character to point fingers at oneself. By oneself I don't just mean an individual but also the city/state/society/country that one belongs to. On the other hand it's very easy to point fingers at everybody else.

To truly improve Bihar and India we need to point out the flaws in the system. Finding a 'bug' is the first step in fixing it. If you refuse to believe that there is a 'bug' in the system (and call it a 'feature' in the system instead) you will never fix it. People who say that we should not find and publicize the flaws in our society are like the husband who hits his wife and then asks her to cry softly so that the neighbor cannot hear her cry.

This mentality has failed us for too long. My suggestion is that if you find a flaw in our societies then don’t be shy and afraid. Be sure to point it out loudly without caring what the others think. Fixing the problem is much more important than some fake pride. If each one of us takes care of our own ‘Raja Beta’ then we can protect our society, which at the moment is unleashed with millions of ‘Raja Betas’ who thrive and prosper under the doting eyes of their community/families.
 

Comments:
If each one of us correct our own failings the society will become much better. However, the psyche that most critical people suffer from is that they point ten fingers and ten toes at other people, other societies and other countries but none at themselves, their neighborhood or the society they live in. No responsibility should come back to them.

One gives away things one does not need. As for example advice. PD has been overflowing with hollow advice but, in comparison, it has not percolated to a penny's worth of action. The raja betas can do nothing for their mother land but complain. When the same betas run their families they do not complain. They find solutions and implement it. On PD, it is different. Some of us are always whining about things being wrong but I have not seen any plan of action emerging. One reader suggested collecting some money and got pounced upon. After that no one has dared. So there are no solutions. We come here to complain about whose backyard is dirtier. We complain for the sake of complaining and become more are a part of the problem than a part of the solution.

Let us face it. Do we come to PD fired by a sense of belonging for Bihar and India or do we peep in to see if there is something worth reading for self-entertainment? I think each one of us have to answer that question. If you are fired with patriotic zeal do something on the ground. One little action will speak louder than the lorry loads of advice piled in voluminous articles by self-appointed advisors to the PM/CM/whoever cares to read all that. If it is for entertainment, let us not be hypocritical, admit it and then write something entertaining for heaven's sake. Do not bore other readers to death with loads of ill-conceived advices. I have seen readers attempting to break away from this self-imposed advisor mould but those articles go un-commented. Write advise and all the advisors perk up, put on their reading glasses, reignite their visions of Ram-rajya and load copious amounts of advise to the original article. Sometimes the advisors cross swords. It is amusing.

My advise to the permanent self-appointed advisors on PD is as follows: The people closest to you are the members of your family. Try finding flaws and advising them 24x7 and you will realize what a counter productive exercise it is. Is that the reason they lighten their hearts by finding flaws and advising imaginary figures on PD. The modern day Don Quixotes who kill imaginary enemies not with arms but bore them to death with advise.

I hope some readers will contribute some interesting articles. Occasional suggestions, which are practical, well thought of and implementable are fine but, as things stand, we are up to our ears in Quixotic fault finding and advise coming from people who do not believe their own words as they are not willing to spend a penny over them. So those words are not worth a penny. - Rajesh Chaubey - Apr. 12, 2006

I asked one of my friends from Kerala, "How is Kerala?". He softly replied, "Kerala is known as God's own land". I know Kerala too has it's share of problems but I appreciated his part of marketing the brand "Kerala" when he, himself, choose to live out of this place.

Every system has bugs, but It's the features which are trumpeted around and bugs are religiously and internally worked out. No product waits to completely fix all the problems before it go to market. Bihar is making it's all effort to wining the confidence of investors, businessman, tourist etc, let's not exaggerate the problems and paint it black in the air to harm those sincere efforts. Let us not complain just for the sake of complaining when we are hardly doing anything for it. - Md. Aslehullah, Dubai, UAE - Apr. 12, 2006


Long back I had seen a cartoon. A man gets scolded by his boss in office for not keeping files properly. He feels like yelling back but the odds are too great. So he returns home fuming. He enters the house, finds a towel on the sofa and yells at his wife. Now the wife is fuming. She yells at her daughter for not arranging the house. Now the daughter is fuming. She goes and slaps her little brother for littering things. Now the little boy is fuming. He goes and kicks the family dog. The family dog whines not knowing what the kick was for.

I suspect writing advice on PD is a similar chain of events. People absorb advice reluctantly at the work place. When they try to find faults and advice at home there are long faces, swollen cheeks, non-cooperation and, at unfortunate times, return advice. So battered by advice from all quarters they run the the oasis provided by PD. Aha!!! Now there is no threat of return advice!!! What a relief!!! They fire advice in all directions. President, PM, CM, DM, and cm (common man) all are targeted. The advisor feels brilliant and empowered. The firing continues till the advisor feels avenged. By now he is happy but tired and goes to sleep with the satisfaction of a victorious General who has addressed his troops and told them to "Sweat in peace, lest they bleed in war".

Next day is a repeat performance. - Rajesh Chaubey - Apr. 13, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2006, PatnaDaily.Com.