Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Politics in Academia

by Ashwini Kumar Singh
Director-DREDS (District Rural Education Development Society)
Gopalganj, Bihar

January 17, 2006

Readers Write

 

The controversy created by HRD ministry over opening up of IIM, Bangalore's branch in Singapore, again shows how politics play spoilsport in the academics. On the other hand the counterparts abroad are giving autonomy to their institutions of national repute and making them more successful in all avenues. Earlier it was Murli Manohar Joshi, now it is Arjun Singh.

By opening a branch in Singapore, IIM Bangalore will not only get financial aid but also the exposure at international level for Indian institutions. It can also cater to the needs of the wards of 9% population of Singaporeans which are Indians. The BITS, Pilani, Rajasthan is one such example which has opened its campus in Knowledge Village, Dubai apart from one in Goa.

Our institutions, despite being research and education oriented, are pressurized to think about the political, bureaucratic obligations. If any institute is financially independent, it should be given a chance to have tie-ups with other world class institutions and offshore study campuses for their research activities. They should be given full autonomy.

On the other side, these institutions are unable to fulfill the internal demand-supply chain. Only 1% of the CAT aspirants get through IIMs. The need of the hour is to either increase the intake of seats or increase the number of IIMs or say to open an IIM in each state as in the case of National Law School, Bangalore. After the need was felt such seven law schools were opened in Hyderabad, Kolkata, Bhopal, Jodhpur, Raipur, Gandhinagar and Kochi. One more at Lucknow is under consideration.

Comments:
The recent developments are really sad. I don’t know why HRD ministry is unnecessarily trying to stop IIM expansion. Even the Maharashtra govt. didn’t provide land for expansion only because IIM was not ready to reserve seats for Maharashtrians. Everything seems really ridiculous. it was an in house development, why not central govt. intervened that time. - Nawin, NJ - Jan. 20, 2006

I agree to disagree on the topic "politics in academia". There are certain institution which are very premier in our country and IIMs are among them. These institution don't necessarily need expansion but the government's utmost attention to beat the world class institution.

Instead of expanding the branches in other country its better to improve the infrastructure, R & D facilities, Faculty qualities etc. of these IIMs and making it better than Harvard, Standford, Wharton.

Does Harvard has any branches?? Don't they attract international students?? - Kumud Ranjan - Jan. 20, 2006


Ashwini ji, I don't have any insight on whether IIM should expand or not so I will not comment on your article.

But I am glad that people like you who are on a very responsible position in Bihar are PatnaDaily writers (and probably reader too).

I will request that you please pass on any useful information you find here to your superiors so that they can be of some use. - Kaushal Das - Jan. 20, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2004, PatnaDaily.Com.