Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Reverse Brain Drain - Good? Bad?

by Indra

January 1, 2006

Readers Write

 

I don’t know why but I don’t get excited when I read or hear news such as ‘brain drain in reverse’ and NASSCOM estimates that says 30,000 professionals have moved back to India. Perhaps I don’t like them serving some companies as employees, as they will be doing the same what they were doing in US too. And there may be many here already who can occupy the chair with same performance efficiency or better. However, I get real pleasure when I find someone from US coming to start an enterprise of his own. In the early part of this year when we were in the US, I used to suggest every Indian young man that we met to have an ambition to start some enterprise and get trained accordingly while working for the American companies. However, I understand very well that every one can’t be an entrepreneur neither every one likes to take the risk that a business demands.

Some 80,000 students every year are still going for higher professional studies to US and many more to other countries too including China. And I don’t grumble about it. It happened in past too, when IITs were already there on the scene. There is nothing wrong if the Indian students are migrating to US for higher studies such as masters or PhD, in which US provides the best facilities in the world. Indian institutes but for some, still don’t provide the post-graduate professional education of world class standard. Even if these migrants work abroad, the country is the major beneficiary through the huge remittances that they make. Last year, it was about $24 billion.

Perhaps in the same way I was not excited, when the new CM of Bihar promised the other day to create conditions so that the migration of the people of Bihar stops. His government can only provide employment for menial work such as one based on the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005. Unfortunately, Bihar could neither develop service sector nor manufacturing over the years.

There is nothing wrong if the people are going out for better opportunities. I feel proud to see the young men from Bihar carrying out small and medium business in NCR. But I feel bad when they engage themselves for menial work for nominal remunerations. Fortunately, I find the number of people from Bihar in menial work is going down.

I wish the new CM ensured that these boys get good education before they leave their village homes or towns. The new government must provide all level of trade education and training of diploma and degree level. Bihar needs its trade schools to provide religiously high skill and knowledge to their schools and certainly not the paper that is called diploma or degree. Even if they are to work as masons, plumbers, welders, carpenters, or plumbers, they must have the skill to get good remunerations. And then they shall be in good demand even outside the state or the country.

A redeployment based on skill at village level is also necessary, and the people there must be accordingly prepared and trained. Beside good masons, carpenters, and barbers, villages must now have skilled persons who can repair diesel motors, tractors, harvesters, motorcycles and scooters; and electricians to maintain music systems, telephones, and cellular. And owners or users are not made to depend on technicians in towns.

Comments:
Bravo! A very well written and analytical article! I really enjoyed reading it. The author makes several very good points. These points go against the conventional view of things and very amply demonstrate the flaw in conventional thought.

I agree with the author that instead on focusing solely on higher education in Bihar, both the Government and the people should look at the vast spectrum of jobs between the labourer and the professional that the new economic order is bringing in.

There is a limited market of professionals and not everyone has the 'gift of Saraswati', resources or the iron will to complete 4 years of Technical Education. For the thousands who do, there are not enough jobs. This leads to disillusionment, underemployment and frustration.

For the day lobourers, especially those who migrate outside, the condition is most wretched. It is purely a hand-to-mouth existence and the lot of the person never changes. This segment of the workforce from Bihar is most exploited.

The new economic order is ushering in a plethora of jobs of the Technician level. These jobs that require High School education and some vocational training can offer very good pay. These vocational careers are going to be the sway of tomorrow in India. Medical Technologists (x-ray, CAT, MRI), Pathology, Auto Repair, Air Conditioning Techs, Plumbers, Electricians, Building Trade Specialists, Glass installers, Photo copier technician, Electrical Equipment repair, Machine operators, Manufacturing techs. ..... the list is endless and I can go on and on for hours.

Education in the new Bihar needs to focus on producing a workforce of technicians. The goal should to take kids finishing High School and to offer them Vocational training and Certification. Government should also phase in certification requirements for such professions to ensure that the work is done by someone who has training to complete the work. There is a need also to adopt codes for Building, Electrical, Plumbing work etc, so that quality of work done is not only high, but uniform throughout the state

So far Bihar has supplied cheap labour to the rest of the country. There is no reason why we can't have well paid Bihari Technicians both inside and out of Bihar. - Aarcee - Jan. 3, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2004, PatnaDaily.Com.