Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Bihar Needs Kautilyan Ruthlessness

by Indra

Sept. 22, 2007

Readers Write

 

Many a time I get a shock of life. I got one such yesterday evening. NDTV that I consider reasonably well reporting news channel, kept on pouring unpleasant news from the homeland Bihar.

It started with a crude bomb explosion in the court premises of Patna followed by the news of discovery of bagful of human skulls and bones from a bus in Chhapra, and ended with the news of life term sentences for nine by an Aurangabad court. How can a national channel keep on continuing with so many news reports from just one state? Can’t a big state like Bihar provide media with matter for single good news story? Is the TV channel biased about Bihar?

I felt bad and switched to Zee TV serials the channel my wife patronizes and came on my laptop. But my bad day and perhaps luck continued. One of my acquaintances contacted for chatting. He had returned from Patna after a short holiday there. He was really pained to see no improvement in Bihar. Administration is going in the same old Bihar’s unique way. Officers with proven capability have been shunted to ineffective posting. Present DGP, who is considered as choice because of his caste, is the strong man off the state and close to the CM. He can’t work with abler officers as subordinates. Perhaps Nitish Kumar is suffering humiliated on deteriorating law and order situation in Bihar because of him. Unfortunately like all from Bihar, Nitish Kumar too has a weakness to keep some sycophants around. I was shocked when he wrote, “Earlier it was "Bhu-Shaasan " then "Ku-Shaasan" now its "Ku-Ra-La" in Bihar”. I don’t know the meaning of these, but the whole night I kept on thinking. The morning newspaper had all the news in print with addition of a robbery in train in Bihar and transfer of a large number of DSPs. Will it help?

Perhaps the state requires more of Ramdev and his disciples in all the cities, towns, and villages to conduct the value building programmes as basic requirement.

Please appoint the best policeman of the country (may be Kiran Bedi who recently was superseded by her junior) to head Bihar law and order administration. Why should the CM be so keen to keep the men, who are having very poor reputation because of his caste bias?

I again repeat the suggestions with one more request from history.

Go for Kautilyan ruthlessness. As the history says, Ashoka undoubtedly evinced the Kautilyan ruthlessness essential to gaining the throne and the same Kautilyan ruthlessness in retaining it.

The perception of the people about the ruler is pretty important. Nitish Kumar brought a hope for all the people of Bihar living in and out of the state. Somehow, the hopes are getting belied, as nothing visible is happening fast enough to spread the sweet fragrance of change for better all around.
 

Comments:
Feels sad to see that so much being raised and then this reverse gear. Of course things have improved a little. The downhill slide has stopped and we are moving forward. Latest WB Report on Bihar having 8.5% GDP raised some hope. I know the march of progress will not stop and government will change but development will not stop. However, speed could be better. Also these caste ridden decision making of govt needs change. Not only in reality but also in terms of perception

Very good points brought out by Indra jee. Many thanks. - Atul Kumar, Tristate, USA - Sept. 24, 2007

I agree with your views on Sri Nitish Kumar jee and his some top bureaucrats. I don't understand why he (Nitish jee) is not thinking about calling Smt Kiran Bedi or Sri K.P.S Gill or any other strong and able officers on the post of DGP for ameliorating situation of Law and order in Bihar. Why he didn't act yet when improving law and order was the first priority of the state .

Why he doesn't understand that Investors will never even think about investment in Bihar unless they see light of good law and order as well as good infrastructure. After global Bihar Meet, people started thinking about investment in the state. He should not do the same blunder what previous govt had done in the past. - Bibhuti Bikramaditya, Seoul, S Korea - Sept. 24, 2007


It's bad to hear such news about Bihar as stated by the author. If this is the reality then I am afraid, our state has changed the name of the ruler and not the way of ruling. Nitish Kumar was thought of noble wisdom, indiscrimination, performance oriented governance by the poor public of Bihar. If he is going the same way his predecessors went, they the ray of hope, which arrived after a long wait, is again going to vanish behind dark clouds of casteism, nepotism and no-work attitude.

I would like the author, Indraji, to tell us the name of the friend who was chatting with him (full name). I am sure that the friend's second name would start with “Y”. Why I am so sure about the surname? Because this kind of casteist statement could be made by a person, who himself has a caste-oriented mind and has enjoyed this own caste-dominated government. Therefore, first he enquired the surnames of all the officials in the government and then came to conclusion that, the government is being surrounded by a particular caste with which he doesn’t share a good bonding.

Indraji may show unawareness about the meaning of the short terms expressed by his friends, as he always does in order to present himself as a neutral and development oriented futuristic personality, but the truth is that he knows very well what these mean. He may fear telling, but I know that “Bhu-Shaasan” means “Bhoomihaar”, “Ku-Shaasan” means “Kurmi-Shaasan”, and “Ku-Ra-La ….” means “Kurmi-Rajput-Laala ….” . Its shocking that his good friend forgot to spell “Yad-Shaasan”, which was very much present for last fifteen years and due to its casteist approach, was responsible for the bad condition of Bihar. That’s the point which made me think about the bias present in author and his friend’s mind about the government and related bodies.

I would like to suggest Indraji (more to his friend) that casteism has already eaten up the base of society and economy of our poor state, please for god sake, stop following the destructive path, which may bring disaster to our already-ruined state. Criticism is a tool towards development, but on the grounds stated by the author, would take us nowhere but the doomsday. - Ravish Kumar, Hyderabad - Sept. 26, 2007


I confess that I am very poor in finding out the details of the abbreviation. My IQ on this subject is very poor. I hate the caste based relations. It is basically a mirage that it helps. I wish whatever I mentioned in my write-up because of a communication from an acquaintance are all wrong. If it has hurt anyone I feel sorry and apologize. But I feel bad when I hear any bad news from Bihar. I do also feel bad when I read other states such as Orissa and Assam also doing better than Bihar. Those in power can do that. I did work very hard to get things improved in very small job that I was doing. I expect that from every one. One doesn't get that opportunity again and again in life. - Indra - Sept. 27, 2007


Hi Folks

Greetings from a very rainy London!

Changing gears. I hear a lot of folks complain about the current flood situation in Bihar and I can't help but wonder …..same old…same old?

What really did upset me was the barbaric behavior of some of our people. For instance dragging of that poor guy on a motor bike by a police men then killing of those alleged thieves by people in Vaishali. I wonder why our people are getting so frustrated. Maybe because the police have failed them? Whatever the reason might be, I still think it was all a very barbaric act and I am really ashamed of whatever happened.

You can't really expect a state to progress if the people living in the state start loosing their humanity.

Let us put some humanity back into our people. And with regards to the investment going into Bihar state, let me just say this, if investors can allocate capital into countries like LAO PDR, Sudan and Chad then I don't see why Bihar can't be invest-able. - Sanjeev Kumar (London, England) - Oct. 4, 2007

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2006, PatnaDaily.Com.